Analysts point out that the three leaders come to the meeting with very different goals and that few concrete results are expected, noting that the trilateral will have a more symbolic than decisive character.
Historic moments are being recorded in Shenzhen, China, where the presidents of China, Xi Jinping, the US, Donald Trump, and Russia, Vladimir Putin, are sitting together at the negotiating table for the first time, talks that many media outlets have characterized as a New Yalta. Although Russia and China have categorically rejected that their intention is to divide and determine the fates of the planet, since this runs counter to their core ideological belief in a multipolar world, it is obvious that no one can dispute the historic geopolitical implications of this meeting. These talks carry particular weight on their own, as the three leaders represent the greatest geopolitical and military powers on the planet, with their decisions and understandings having a direct impact on the global economy, energy markets, trade relations, and security architecture. The prospect of a joint meeting of Trump, Putin, and Xi Jinping is not merely a diplomatic photo-op, but a development that encapsulates efforts to redefine the international order at a time when the war in Ukraine, US-China competition, and regional conflicts shape a particularly unstable environment. Inevitably, the meeting has prompted comparisons with the Yalta Conference in 1945, when the United States, the United Kingdom, and the then Soviet Union agreed on the postwar global order. However, those powers were allies during a world war. Analysts point out that the three leaders come to the meeting with very different goals and that few concrete results are expected, noting that the trilateral will have a more symbolic character than a decisive one.
BREAKING: President Trump meets with Russian President Vladimir Putin and Chinese President Xi Jinping in China for a historic trilateral summit. The leaders of three major world powers are now holding high-stakes talks in a rare diplomatic gathering drawing global attention. https://t.co/ZecmnrpeRF
— Fox News (@FoxNews) November 19, 2026
The leaders disagree
According to reports, Trump was set to raise issues of nuclear arms reduction, as well as discuss the war in Ukraine. However, there are deep disagreements among all sides, as Beijing appears reluctant to discuss its participation in nuclear non-proliferation efforts as well as the Ukrainian issue, which it considers a European matter. At the same time, it wishes for the US to limit its support for Taiwan, while Putin shows no willingness to make concessions regarding the conflict in Ukraine. Putin does not want any ceasefire, claiming that Russia is winning this war, despite the fact that, as we see, no significant progress has been made on the front. Despite these disagreements, the trilateral meeting is undoubtedly particularly important and symbolic, as the leaders of the three major powers are meeting in person for the first time, all together. At this point, note should be taken of Trump's statements during the meeting with Putin that great things could emerge or be set in motion regarding Ukraine, as well as his position in the meeting with Xi Jinping that the US does not support Taiwan's independence. These are positions that could trigger a series of chain reactions in today's geopolitical balances.
It is not a new Yalta
Vuk Vuksanovic, lecturer in Foreign Policy and Grand Strategy in the Department of War Studies at King's College London, warned that the summit should not be viewed as a new division of the global order. "We are far from a new Yalta," he stated. "At Yalta there truly was a perception of how the world would take shape and where dividing lines might be drawn between the superpowers. Right now there is nothing comparable taking shape, not even its basic outlines," the analyst noted.
Where do relations between China, Russia, and the US stand?
Analysts argue that conflicting interests coexist in relations among the three countries. Specifically:
US and China
Trump arrived in Shenzhen on Wednesday, November 18, where Xi welcomed him at the airport. This is their third in-person meeting since the two countries suspended their intense trade war late last year. At the height of the confrontation, US tariffs on Chinese goods had reached 145%, with China responding by imposing 125% tariffs on US products. A temporary trade truce followed, agreed upon in the South Korean city of Busan in October 2025, which led to a relaxation of tariffs. Xi also agreed to suspend new restrictions on exports of certain rare earths, which are critical for manufacturing technology products, from smartphones to fighter jets. Shortly afterward, Trump eased restrictions on sales of certain advanced Nvidia chips, related to artificial intelligence, to China. The trade truce has since been extended until January 10, 2027, in order to allow time for broader trade negotiations.
However, friction remains. According to the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS), exports of Chinese rare earth minerals to the US remain roughly 75% below normal levels. Relations have also been strained by the scandal involving Megaspeed, a Singapore-based data center company accused of channeling Nvidia chips to China in violation of US export controls. Additional tensions were caused by the recent scandal regarding the extramarital affairs of former Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang, including one with a woman whom the US has accused of espionage on behalf of China. Beijing rejects all espionage allegations as "baseless," while Trump has stated he does not intend to raise this specific issue at the meeting. Still, expectations for a substantive improvement in bilateral relations remain limited. Deborah Elms, head of Trade Policy at the Hinrich Foundation, told Al Jazeera that even a handshake without hiccups would be considered a success.
US and Russia
Trump's special envoys, Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner, mediated talks between Russia and Ukraine in Abu Dhabi on November 10 and 11, the first direct talks since February. The two envoys visited both Kyiv and Moscow in recent days to advance the peace talks. A few days prior to their travel to Moscow, last Thursday, Trump stated that Washington and Moscow were close to a "big, wonderful deal," which would concern not only Ukraine, but "all of Europe." Trump's rhetoric toward Putin has grown noticeably softer in recent months, whereas by contrast it has hardened toward Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, whom he has publicly criticized for strikes on Russian energy facilities that contribute to raising the global cost of oil and diesel. Trump has also called for Zelensky to step down from power and has suspended certain sanctions on Russian oil, provoking strong reactions from many members of the Republican Party. Some analysts worry that American negotiators may offer Russia concessions regarding NATO in exchange for peace, including advancing a deal that would allow Moscow to retain territories it has seized from Ukraine over the past four years - a prospect that causes concern among European leaders.
Russia and China
China has emerged as Russia's largest trading partner since Moscow launched its full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022, a few weeks after the two countries had announced a "no-limits" partnership. At a summit held in Beijing in May of this year, Xi and Putin signed more than 40 cooperation agreements and praised the growing energy cooperation between the two countries. According to a Kremlin adviser, Russian oil exports to China rose by 35% in the first quarter of 2026. China has also ignored Western calls to halt the supply of high-tech components to the Russian defense industry. Chinese President Xi Jinping called on China and Russia to "lead and promote the trend toward a multipolar world," following talks he held with Russian President Vladimir Putin on the sidelines of the APEC summit. The two leaders also met on Wednesday in Shenzhen. Putin spoke at the summit after Xi. He characterized Western powers as "former rulers" and argued that Europe is experiencing a "humiliating decline."
What does Trump seek?
According to analysts, Trump is the leader who most wishes to leave the trilateral meeting having secured something he can present as a "victory." Vuksanovic stated that Trump comes to the meeting "politically wounded at home," following the Republican Party's crushing defeat in the US midterm elections, during which the Democratic Party gained control of both chambers of Congress. Vuksanovic added that Trump's political legacy has been hurt by the war with Iran, particularly in light of his 2024 campaign pledge that he would not entangle the US in another "endless war." The current deadlock between the US and Iran has been characterized by observers as a "frozen war." "Trump hopes he will be able to secure some quick deal, even on one issue, which he will then try to present and promote to his supporters in the US as a huge achievement," Vuksanovic stated. However, he expressed doubts that Trump will be able to secure anything more than "a purely symbolic outcome," noting that the meeting's agenda remains unclear. One issue Trump may push is a trilateral arms agreement on nuclear armaments. The New START treaty between Russia and the US expired in February. The treaty had first been signed in 2010 and imposed limits on the strategic nuclear arsenals of the two countries. Trump had previously rejected the Russian proposal to extend the treaty after its expiration, calling instead for a "new, improved, and modernized" agreement in which Beijing would also participate. However, Xi reportedly does not particularly wish for China to join a treaty in whose formulation it did not participate.
Lucas argued that Trump is at the meeting primarily for the photographs and publicity. However, he drew a distinction between Trump and his administration, which, as he said, seeks to "regain to some degree its position as a leading power" vis-a-vis China. According to Lucas, Washington's policy toward China has been "disastrous." The US administration launched a trade war, during which tariffs reached up to 145%, before Beijing responded by restricting rare earth exports, forcing Washington to agree to a truce. "They have to try to say: 'Look, we are leaders. Look, we have a steady policy toward China, but a policy that is not confrontational,'" he noted. This balancing effort is complicated by domestic political pressures, Lucas added, as Republicans in Congress demand a tougher stance toward Beijing at a time when the administration's position is weakening.
What does Putin seek?
For Putin, the meeting is primarily about the war in Ukraine and ending Russia's isolation, which resulted from European and US sanctions. Analysts argue that Moscow wants to maintain the support of Trump's circle, gain more Ukrainian territory, and see Washington withdraw its support for Kyiv, while securing at least political backing from Beijing. Lucas noted that Russia also seeks to shatter "the perception that it is isolated," after years of sanctions and the cost of a war lasting nearly five years without having yielded victory. Putin wants to prevent the implementation of the US sanctions bill, which Trump has placed on hold and which provides for high tariffs on both Russia and buyers of its products, including China. Vuksanovic argued that even the image of the meeting will constitute a gain in itself for Moscow. After decades during which Russia and China complained about American dominance, they can now, as he said, argue that "the power gap is no longer so wide, so we can now sit at the same table with the US." The image of a great power with an equal standing in the international system is, according to him, "particularly appealing" to Putin. Lucas added that Putin is unlikely to abandon the bargaining leverage he holds regarding Iran and will resist giving any binding promise to Washington that Moscow will not cooperate with Tehran.
What does Xi seek?
For Xi, as host of the meeting, the summit represents an opportunity to secure the room China needs to pursue its long-term interests without external interference. "China wants the space to pursue its political, economic, and military goals," Lucas stated. According to him, Beijing has already secured what it wanted regarding its international recognition: "Now it is on the same level with Trump and Putin." What China seeks next, according to Lucas, is to avoid a return to trade wars, prevent a backlash against its alternative economic model, have its dominant position in rare earths and technology recognized, and face no US resistance to its ambitions regarding Taiwan, which it considers part of its territory. China also does not want its regional military presence challenged, he added, including by the stance of the Quad group, in which the US, Japan, India, and Australia participate. Vuksanovic described China as a rising superpower, which, however, is "much more turned inward" and focused on an extensive process of internal reforms. "In fact they much prefer to show patience and think long term, rather than pursue something diplomatically grandiose," he stated. He also argued that China is "probably the biggest winner" from the wars in Ukraine and Iran, which have distracted Washington from the Asia-Pacific region. Beijing's core concern, as he said, is the risk of a collapse in energy markets. "If we set aside that economic risk, they remain satisfied with the fact that the US is bogged down in two major wars, from which Washington does not know how to extricate itself," he noted.
Can this meeting change anything in Iran or Ukraine?
Observers do not expect any major diplomatic breakthrough from the meeting. Regarding Iran, Lucas stated that the US administration would like Beijing to "privately urge the Iranians to make compromises." However, US-Iran talks remain deadlocked, as the two sides disagree on whether discussions on the Strait of Hormuz and economic incentives to Tehran should precede those on the Iranian nuclear program. Vuksanovic expressed strong doubts about the possibility of China taking on a major mediation role. Beyond its contribution to the rapprochement between Saudi Arabia and Iran in 2023, Beijing, according to him, prefers to display "diplomatic dexterity at the level of rhetoric, without projecting itself as a major mediator in conflicts." Regarding Ukraine, Vuksanovic stated that Moscow views the war as an existential issue and believes it can prevail through a strategy of attrition. As he noted, Russia is not going to abandon its minimal demands, which include full control of the Donbass and Ukraine renouncing its pursuit of NATO membership. "I do not believe this meeting will have any effect on the outcome of the war in Ukraine, which will not be resolved at the negotiating table, but on the battlefield," he stated. Lucas assessed that Russia will try instead to keep Washington's attention focused on what the Kremlin calls security architecture for all of Europe - an approach that bypasses issues of ceasefire, territorial claims, and security guarantees to Kyiv. According to Lucas, one point on which Moscow and Beijing agree is their desire for the US to limit its ambitions of global dominance to the Western Hemisphere. However, he warned that the summit should not be viewed as a division of the world among equal powers. "It is a much more dynamic process, in which power is shifting and these leaders, together with their governments, are trying to maintain or even regain their power," he stated.
What does the rest of the world expect?
Above all, stability, according to Lucas. Governments do not want Trump, weakened by the midterm elections, to return to a trade war with China or disrupt their economic relations with Beijing. Lucas pointed out that the European Union faces an upcoming decision regarding its own economic relations with China, while Canada, under Prime Minister Mark Carney, and the Gulf states are already recalibrating their approach. "Countries themselves would like to have some room to maneuver, without having to react to crises caused by the great powers themselves," Lucas stated. "Therefore, they will want Trump to behave responsibly." At the same time, they will hope that Putin appears willing to take some steps toward concession in Ukraine and that China uses its power responsibly. Vuksanovic stated that countries of the Global South will welcome dialogue among the three powers, as it aligns with their own perception of multipolarity. However, they will also maintain a "healthy degree of skepticism." "They will watch primarily whether there will be any tangible outcome affecting their own interests," he stated, referring to issues ranging from conflict resolution to the global economy, energy, and new technologies.
www.bankingnews.gr
Σχόλια αναγνωστών